Troy Nicholson is best known as the batsman who robbed Chris Hope of a half-century, after going out when Hope was on 4, the only time he got off the mark in Willowfest 2005. Nicholson has angered many fans by his lack of Dedication in the field, failing to make an attempt at several catchable balls. In a move that angered many fans, Nicholson withdrew from the squad for Willowfest 2007. He returned amidst much controversy in 2008, and in his first innings against the Prior Pigeons, Nicholson tried to pull a ball from middle stump, ensuring Dedication had its second tie in just 4 years.